Try The Diet Solution program for $1.00  |    Free Downloads   |    Every other Day Diet - Guaranteed Results.   |    Skinny-Gain Muscle Fast here!  |    7 Minute Muscle  |      
Product Reviews by AtoZfitness

Isabel De Los Rios FREE Nutrition Bonus e-book Download.

The meal plans and nutrition principles that follow are a culmination of 15 years of research and study into exactly what works to achieve a lean body. I assure you that none of these rules are “unhealthy” or “extreme”. On the contrary. They are the best principles you can incorporate to ...

Read More

The Fat Burning Furnace Reviewed

With a name like Fat Burning Furnace, the first thing that usually comes to mind is a solution which will burn all the excess fat that you have – fast. Is this the premise behind the weight loss program called Fat Burning Furnace? That is exactly what we will try to ...

Read More

Eggs with 22x more omega-3's?

A quick announcement before the omega-3 eggs article today: Today, Feb 23, 2010 is Mike's 34th birthday, and to celebrate, he has decided to put his Fat Burning Kitchen program on sale for HALF price for 3-days! This is only the 2nd sale he has ever had in his 5 years of ...

Read More

The Diet Solution Program Review

Review of The Diet Solution Program: The Program that Promises F.at Loss along with an incredible amount of Health and Vitality. The Diet Solution Program promises a complete and comprehensive weight loss program that will not only help you lose body f.at, but guarantees you increased energy, health and vitality all ...

Read More

Lean Muscle Workouts , Lean Hybrid Muscle Building -Explained

Q. What is the Lean Hybrid Muscle program? A. Every single day countless guys decide embark on a quest to get lean, build muscle or do both—and that’s a great thing. The sad part is that most of those guys won’t see the results they’d hoped to see and after a ...

Read More

7 Minute Muscle Reviewed by Sarah (cpt)

7MM for short. And that’s what this is about. Short. Save time. Train fast and furious and get on with other things. Well, fast and furious, not quite. When you buy the 7MM e-book, the download page also gives you 6 videos showing you how to do the training involved. ...

Read More

The Best Arm Exercises You've Never Heard Of Reviewed

So what's the first thing you think of when you think of "arm training" - if you're like a lot of trainers, you immediately think barbell curls and pushdowns. Or dumbell curls and dips, etc. The "standard" exercises, right? Well, it's time to think outside the box! Or as ...

Read More

Mike geary's Fat Burning Kitchen Reviewed

I’ve been reading a really great book this week. With the hours I work, I’m only able to read so much per day, but I’m loving every page. It’s always fun to see someone actually dare say out loud what many suspect and many know but mindfully suppress from common knowledge. What ...

Read More

Jon Benson’s Every other Day Diet e-book review by Sarah

I’ve told you about Jon Benson’s Every Other Day Diet (EODD) before, and both Lewis and I have been using the easy-to-follow principles for months now. What is it, half a year or more? Now, Jon Benson didn’t just sit back and relax, happy to have shared his EODD with ...

Read More


The Creatine Grave Yard

| Print this Post | 1,124 views |

---------------------------------------------------------------------- |
The Creatine Grave Yard
---------------------------------------------------------------------- |
 

The Creatine Grave Yard
By Will Brink © 2009

Looks like another “high tech” form of creatine has got one foot planted firmly in the creatine grave yard. What is the creatine graveyard? It’s where forms of creatine - other then monohydrate - go when either science has shown them inferior to monohydrate, and or it’s life cycle of hype has come to and end.

I refer specifically to creatine ethyl ester (CEE). As with the many “high tech” forms of creatine before it, all manner of claims were/are made about how superior it is to creatine monohydrate (CM). It always starts the same. First the company will invent a long list of negatives about CM such as “poorly absorbed” or “causes bloat” or “is not stable” and then goes onto claim their form of creatine has solved all those invented negatives. The problem is, the data already shows CM does not suffer from virtually any of the negatives they invent, nor do they show their form “cures” those negatives. Sellers of CCE for example claimed CEE was better absorbed and utilized vs. CM, and that has been shown to be nonsense. There have been several in vitro (test tube) studies pointing to the fact CEE is inferior to CM, but a recent study done in humans puts a final nail in the coffin as far as I am concerned. This study is titled “The effects of creatine ethyl ester supplementation combined with heavy resistance training on body composition, muscle performance, and serum and muscle creatine levels” The full study is public access and can be read here:

CEE Study

Warning, the abstract is confusing and not well written. If you read the full paper, it’s clearer. If you don’t have the time or interest to read it, the take home is: although all subjects in this study (CEE vs. CM vs. Placebo) experienced approximately the same effects; they all had improvements in bodycomp and got stronger. Why? Because they used untrained subjects in the study. Thus, a drawback of this study was due to using untrained people, they couldn’t differentiate between PL, CEE, and CM in terms of effects on bodycomp and strength within that time period as newbies always make fast progress in the beginning. No news there.

However, the study did achieve the essential point, which is it clearly showed the claims of CEE false: CEE had much higher creatinine levels and lower muscle creatine levels compared to CM in this study, thus, yet again, the claims by sellers of CEE that it’s superior to CM and that CM is “poorly absorbed” or “causes bloat,” or my favorite “CM is not stable,” etc are false. They also looked at changes in water compartments (CEE actually had a trend toward greater extra cellular water then CM BTW, so there goes that stupid “no bloat” claim for CEE…) and other issues claimed to make CEE superior, and it failed.

CEE is less stable then CM, increases creatinine to a much greater extent then CM, and is inferior for increasing muscle creatine levels to CM. This study is not perfect by any means, but when combined with what else exists, and the counter studies sellers of CEE offer (which is to say zero), well you don’t have to be a scientist to see the writing on the wall there…

CEE will be added to the creatine graveyard with a ton of others all claiming to be superior to CM which all started with big claims and now sit in the grave yard.

Two essential points about the grave yard before we get to that:



(1) Because they are in the grave yard does not mean they are worthless. Some forms, such as magnesium creatine chelate for example looked promising, but a head to head study with CM found it no better. Remember, another form does not have to show it’s the equal of CM, it has to show it’s superior to CM per its claims. Forms such as creatine pyruvate and many others on the list may be just as effective as CM, but not superior, so it comes down to cost. Others on the list have in fact been proven inferior to CM in studies, such as serum creatine, various liquid creatine versions, and now CEE. Serum creatine was all the rage a few years ago, and studies found not only was it inferior to CM in every respect, it contained virtually no creatine! Of course, there were still those on the various forums using ‘bro logic’ with “bro, I don’t care what the studies say, it works like da bomb for me!” posts, but I digress….Finally, other forms on the list simply lack any data at all to compare to CM. The companies selling these forms will routinely make claims of superiority with nadda for hard data to support them. Therefore, it’s impossible to really separate fact from fiction (i.e., marketing hype) to recommend them.

Me, I will use what has literally hundreds of studies to support its efficacy and safety over a form with zero data to support it’s claims of superiority over CM. Thus, they get put into the grave yard. Future studies may get them out of the graveyard, but I aint holding my breath…

(2) CM is not perfect. It’s not very soluble, and in about 30% of users, does not appear to work at all. At higher doses, generally above 3g-5g or so in a single dose, can cause stomach upset for some, among other small, but significant drawbacks for some users. Therefore, I am in favor of continued research into improved delivery technologies, improved forms of creatine, and so on. I’m all for it, but as they say, don’t piss on me and tell me it’s raining. In God we trust, everyone else must show data. Hard data talks, BS walks.

I could randomly take two forms from the list below, say dicreatine malate and creatine ethyl carbonate ester and make dicreatine malate creatine ethyl carbonate*, but would it be superior to CM? Unknown as there would be no data. I could just invent a bunch of unproven claims like others do and sell the stuff… Do companies just invent a form of creatine for no other reason then it sound “high tech”? Hell, one company (BSN) is currently in court over one form they sell, called CEM3 or “Creatine Ethyl Ester Malate” which according to the charges “does not exist and is impossible to manufacture”! As I said, CM is not perfect and I am all for continued research into improved (vs. just different!) forms of creatine and or improved delivery technologies, but companies should do their due diligence on these products and stop with all the hype and CM bashing to sell unproven products.

So, without further delay, here is my current list for the creatine graveyard:

The Creatine Graveyard List:

Creatine ethyl ester (CEE)
creatine pyruvate
creatine taurinate
creatine ethyl ester malate
creatine ethyl carbonate ester
creatine gluconate
creatine malate
dicreatine malate
tricreatine malate
creatine citrate
tricreatine citrate
Kre-Alkalyn
creatine phosphate
creatine alpha-ketoglutarate
creatine-6,8-thioctic Acid-ketoisocaproic Acid Calcium (CREAKIC)
creatine pyroglutamate
“conjugated creatine” (Con-Cret)
magnesium creatine chelate
creatine anhydrous
dicreatine orotate
tricreatine orotate
creatine alpha-amino butyrate
creatine HMB
“titrated creatine”
“creatine serum”
“liquid creatine”

Also:
glycocyamine (precursor)
creatinol-o-phosphate (analog)

* = for the sake of an example. I have no idea if such a form is chemically possible, nor do I care.

Will Brink's biography:

Will Brink is the owner of the Brinkzone Blog. Will has over 15 years experience as a respected author, columnist and consultant, to the supplement, fitness, bodybuilding, and weight loss industry and has been extensively published. Will graduated from Harvard University with a concentration in the natural sciences, and is a consultant to major supplement, dairy, and pharmaceutical companies. His often ground breaking articles can be found in publications such as Lets Live, Muscle Media 2000, MuscleMag International, The Life Extension Magazine, Muscle n Fitness, Inside Karate, Exercise For Men Only, Body International, Power, Oxygen, Penthouse, Women’s World and The Townsend Letter For Doctors. Will is the author of the popular e-books, both acommpanied by private members forum access , Bodybuilding Revealeded & Fat Loss Revealed.

Sincerely,
Lewis & Sarah
Publisher - AtoZfitness Total Body Makeover

If you have any questions, you can contact me by clicking here.

 

If you like this post check out these related topics......




Post a Response

You must be logged in to post a comment.



 
Signup for a FREE subscription to my top rated best of the web  weekly newsletter AtoZFitness Weekly Focus on Fitness Newsletter and Fitness Alerts  - a $72 Value -  YOURS FREE as a thank you for visiting my website.

  No Catch 100% FREE     

E-mail:
First Name:
Enter the text as it appears on the image:
  
 

Privacy Note: I will NEVER, EVER sell, rent or give away your email address to anyone for any reason.  I hate spam as much as you do and I will never be a part of it.



  • 125125 banner ad

Post's You Have Viewed


  • Popular

    Search

    Tags

    Archives

  • Most Viewed Posts

  • Our Writers

  • Admin

  • Bad Behavior has blocked 454 access attempts in the last 7 days.